Are Libraries Dying or Thriving?

by Sam on July 28, 2008

One of the towns I used to live in is apparently raising two million dollars for renovations to its library. I told my mother (an active supporter and board member of her public library) that I thought this was a waste of money as the role that libraries play in society has been/will be diminished. I suggested the town is better served spending its money on a public space like a park or garden.

My mother was disgusted.

She informed me that that public libraries are being used as much, or more than ever before. She said that while people don’t take books out as often, instead poorer families still rely on the library as their primary information source: internet access, consumer reports, magazine and even travel guides are hugely popular. The library also is increasingly community oriented offering meeting spaces and discussion groups.

I was pretty surprised to hear all this because I’d assumed that libraries were a dying breed as people increasingly access information online from home, or opt to sit and read at a Barnes & Noble instead. Although I once wrote about how the library was the original Internet I was sure the role of the library as a physical location was greatly diminished.

While I don’t for a minute doubt my mother’s facts on library use, given the choice of allocating money either toward a park or toward a library, I would still opt for the park.

How about you?

  • The park idea also depends on where you are. Libraries, especially in unbearably hot climates, like here in Houston, are one of the few public places you can go to, without being sold something. In fact, I am in one right now. Lot's of people around studying, reading books, browsing the web. we couldn't do that at a park. not here.
  • kevinf7
    I dont think libraries are dying just as the radio didn't die out because of television but I do think they need to adapt. Personally I prefer going to the cafe at Borders for most of my book / community and computing needs (just bring a laptop). I think library leaders really need to be more creative and open and experimental. The old traditional days are gone!
  • it is a wrong perception, Even I am engaged in many blogging activities, I often go to libraries for a knowledge which is not available over internet.
  • Ted Bowman
    Why can everyone not win here by having green space added to library roof tops? That way there is a park and free access to information that everyone loves. Some people laugh but this is the case at Georgetown for their hotel on campus http://tinyurl.com/6zfrwo. It looks excellent and saves on heating bills. It would not be that difficult to add wifi to the roof.

    It's win-win.
  • I'm not sure if public libraries are being used more than ever and personally, I would prefer parks. However, libraries do give people with fewer resources an opportunity to access information. Furthermore, they provide a relatively safe place for children to to hang out after school. The city has to consider which project is more important for its residents. Perhaps it was the more appropriate choice to make.
  • Tim
    Invest my tax dollars in libraries, not parks.

    Libraries help people help themselves and enrich their lives. I started using mine after realizing that of the several books a month I order from Amazon, only a few were keepers. Since I have started going regularly to pick up books that I reserved online, I have amazed to see the range and number of people using the library. The computers there are always full of people. Often with people working on resumes, etc. There is really no private substitute for the public good that a library provides.

    Parks on the other hand are rarely well run by government. Here in Atlanta our "crown jewel" park was getting very rundown until we created a New-York-Central-Park style conservancy that raises its own funds. The conservancy has done an incredible job turning Piedmont Park into a fabulous place again. I have no confidence that the city would have accomplished one tenth as much even with twice the funding.
  • Hey Tim,

    Thanks for your comments! I wasn't intending to get into the fine
    points of who would run/manage the park but your point is well taken.

    I may be spoiled here in New York with Central Park -- it's a jewel
    that gets such incredible use and diversity of users. However a green
    space in the city is likely different than a green space in a suburb
    and yes, a library may give more bang for the buck now....the question
    is should we be investing in the gfuture and the future of public
    green spaces is questionable in my mind
  • Liz
    Although libraries still play an important role in society (like your mother explained), I feel that they need to be more proactive in adjusting to the population's needs of them. However, I know that it is difficult for them to react to constant change on a limited budget. There have been some really interesting discussions on this topic in the GovDoc world. As for the park, I think putting some money towards wi-fi in that park would be my personal preference!
  • Good call Liz! Bringing the virtual library to public places is
    definitely the way to go
  • And who would provide the laptops for people to access the wifi at the park? Although it has mostly failed, Philadelphia tried to bring wifi to the entire city (a private company may be taking over the project). The city soon discovered that in trying to bring the internet to everyone that their target audience did not own computers. So, they then devised a way to provide low cost laptops. The next blunder was in having wifi that was really only accessible outdoors. The city's solution? They told the users to access outside from their front porches or stoops - in many neighborhoods in Philly your laptop would be stolen in about 5 minutes if you used it outside.

    Just another example of the haves of this world not understanding how little the have nots own.

    Taking away the public library is cutting off an entire groups access to knowledge. My library is always packed. I use it instead of buying most books. I don't know if people are reading books but they are using the computers, reading magazines, attending workshops and bringing their toddlers to story time.

    I don't know why we can't have both libraries and nice parks though - it doesn't seem like a lot for any community to ask for.

    "There is not such a cradle of democracy upon the earth as the Free Public Library, this republic of letters, where neither rank, office, nor wealth receives the slightest consideration." ~Andrew Carnegie
blog comments powered by Disqus