George Dyson on Economics, People and Machines

by Sam on July 28, 2009

George Dyson: Theory of Games and Economic Misbehavior (EDGE #295)

…the current misbehavior of our economy, however much it reflects misbehavior by human individuals and institutions, is more a reflection of the behavior of self-reproducing machines and self-replicating codes. We measure our economy in money, not in things. In the age of self-reproducing automata, we can suffer a declining economy, and pandemic unemployment, while still producing as much stuff as people are able to consume. We are facing the first economic downturn to include free cell phones, more automobiles than we have room for (in many locations you can now rent a car for less than it costs to park one) and computers that cost less than a month’s health insurance yet run at billions of cycles per second for years.

Why the growing imbalance between the cost of people and the cost of machines? What prices are going up the fastest? Health care — the cost of maintaining human beings. What prices are going down the fastest? The cost of information and machines. What, really, is health-care reform? Human beings are being cared for by a dysfunctional, antiquated system, and we hope that this can be reformed by adopting efficiencies from the domain of machines. Where will this lead? Are we using computers to sequence, store, and more faithfully replicate our own genetic code, or are computers optimizing our genetic code (and health) so that we can do a better job of replicating them?

George Dyson on Economics, People and Machines
  • http://www.leveragingideas.com Sam Huleatt

    hey Taylor! Yep — i thought it was a really smart insight. One of
    the issues as i see it is that today's entrepreneurs are often
    disrupting current industry models via automation and machine.
    Entrepreneurs come in and radically innovate in ways that save time
    and money or create arbitrage, but often with the function of reducing
    actual need for human involvement. As a result we have a skew in which
    jobs are being lost to machines at a uneplacable rates … and the
    smartest folks in the world focusing on how to do that better. we need
    a new crop of innovators working on companies that can create new
    human job opportunities as well. Maybe this means a focus on services
    or infrastructure —i'm not sure.

  • http://www.taylordavidson.com/writing/ Taylor Davidson

    Completely. One of my (many) interests right now is in “scaling intellectual services”, to bring humanity back into decision-making, to facilitate more exchange of value between people, exchanging knowledge and wisdom, not just data and information. Creating and facilitating those exchanges are the keys behind smart (strategical) web technology / web communities right now.

  • http://www.taylordavidson.com/writing/ Taylor Davidson

    Oddly, the exact same passage that caught my eye. It's an odd insight that the cost of maintaining human beings is rising faster than the cost of machines, but as Dyson implies it's an unsurprising function of recent technological changes.

    But the problem isn't really technology but how we choose to deploy and use it. Perhaps this “market correction” is part of a technology/human balance correction.

  • http://www.leveragingideas.com Sam Huleatt

    hmm..interesting. what are your thoughts on plays like hunch.com?

  • http://www.taylordavidson.com/writing/ Taylor Davidson

    Really haven't dug into hunch enough to say. Aardvark is another example…

  • http://www.behappy2day.com/ Single Maria

    Thanks for the post. Great theory! I have not thought about such things before. Thanks for sharing such a useful information!!!

  • http://www.behappy2day.com/ Single Maria

    Thanks for the post. Great theory! I have not thought about such things before. Thanks for sharing such a useful information!!!

  • http://www.behappy2day.com/ Single Maria

    Thanks for the post. Great theory! I have not thought about such things before. Thanks for sharing such a useful information!!!

  • nikusept

    Cand aveti nevoie de o masina de inchiriat de la oricare din cele doua aeroporturi (Baneasa sau Otopeni) apelati cu incredere la Rentacarfirst ce va pune la dispozitie cele mai bune oferte pentru inchirieri auto baneasa. Rentacarfirst are cel mai diversificat portofoliu de masini cu reviziile la zi si va asteapta sa va bucurati de experienta inchirierii unei masini.